Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Greenberg, Joanne (Goldenberg) - James R. Frakes
Greenberg, Joanne (Goldenberg) - James R. Frakes
JAMES R. FRAKES
Few experiences are more calculated to shrivel a reviewer's heart than to read a publisher's blurb describing a new novel as "an American saga…." So it's a pleasure to discover that ["Founder's Praise"] triumphs over the epithet.
Of course, there's still the problem of the "three generations," but Joanne Greenberg … keeps the lines clear and the relationships functional throughout. And the historical sweep never calls exhausting attention to itself, World War I passing in a single paragraph. But the Dust-Bowl years are dwelt on obsessively, mote by relentless mote. And rightly so, for out of the death of the land in this southeastern Colorado farming community blossoms the "vision of the Presence" granted to Edgar Bisset and transforming him from a silent withdrawn man to an eloquent and joyful giver of life and hope. The transformation is rendered with the kind of open-eyed respect and tenderness with which Sherwood Anderson approached...
[The entire page is 513 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- George E. Gravel
- Time
- The Times Literary Supplement
- R. V. Cassill
- Haskel Frankel
- The Times Literary Supplement
- Brigid Brophy
- Joyce Carol Oates
- Roger Sale
- Victor Howes
- KARY K. WOLFE and GARY K. WOLFE
- James R. Frakes
- Paul Gray
- Hilma Wolitzer
- GERRY McBROOM
- Sanford Pinsker
- Ruth R. Wisse
- Norma B. Williamson
- Meg Elliott Garber
- Robert C. Small
- Susan Dooley
- Gregory Maguire
- Copyright
