Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Gardner, John (Edmund) - Mel Watkins
Gardner, John (Edmund) - Mel Watkins
MEL WATKINS
"Icebreaker" is John Gardner's third James Bond novel, and this British author … has begun to influence the rather stock presentation of the 007 series. In Fleming's hands Bond tended toward a kind of macho cartoonishness…. Mr. Gardner, in this latest novel, has added a touch of the plot subtlety of less insistently action-oriented thrillers….
The most intriguing aspect of this Bond caper, however, is determining who among the Icebreaker team is a double agent. The final scenes are as surprising as they are exciting.
Although Mr. Gardner's Bond is less raffishly macho and arrogant than previously depicted, the spirit of the 007 series remains intact, and few Fleming admirers are likely to object. There is, in fact, something appealing about a James Bond who can react to women with some sympathy and admit to confusion at a crucial moment.
Mel Watkins, in a review of "Icebreaker," in The New York Times Book...
[The entire page is 173 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Francis Hope
- Anthony Boucher
- Elizabeth J. Howard
- Anthony Boucher
- Dorothy B. Hughes
- The Times Literary Supplement
- Reginald Herring
- Allen J. Hubin
- The New Yorker
- The Critic
- Best Sellers
- The Times Literary Supplement
- Vincent J. Colimore
- The Times Literary Supplement
- Charles Nicol
- Marguerite Young
- Marghanita Laski
- Kirkus Reviews
- Joni Bodart
- Charles G. Blewitt
- Newgate Callendar
- Marghanita Laski
- Gene Lyons
- Francis Gavin
- Thomas Bedell
- Newgate Callendar
- Kirkus Reviews
- Jessica Mann
- HENRY McDONALD
- Edward Cline
- Jessica Mann
- Paul Stuewe
- Stanley Ellin
- Robin W. Winks
- John A. Barnes
- Reginald Hill
- Roger Manvell
- Kirkus Reviews
- Anatole Broyard
- Mel Watkins
- Copyright
