Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Erdrich, Louise - Russell Banks (review date 1 November 1986)
Erdrich, Louise - Russell Banks (review date 1 November 1986)
Russell Banks (review date 1 November 1986)
SOURCE: "Border Country," in The Nation, Vol. 243, No. 14, November 1, 1986, pp. 460-63.
[In the following review, Banks asserts that The Beet Queen, in its best sections, rivals the novels of Charles Dickens in socially conscious storytelling.]
The Beet Queen is a Dickensian story, an angry comedy about abandonment and survival, pluck and luck (ambition and coincidence), common sense and pretension, and wise children and foolish adults. The book is structured in an almost classical manner. It opens with a sudden, unpredictable disaster that tosses an ordered world into terrible disarray. It then follows the paths of the half-dozen affected lives through three generations of small triumphs and reversals, long digressions and quick returns, until at last, in a ceremonial event that reunites and reorders the scattered elements of the tale into symmetrical, benign relations, it...
[The entire page is 1537 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- Peter Stitt (review date Winter 1984)
- Russell Banks (review date 1 November 1986)
- Louise Erdrich with Joseph Bruchac (interview date 1987)
- Christopher Vecsey (review date 4 November 1988)
- Thomas Matchie (essay date Summer 1989)
- Annie Finch (review date Summer 1990)
- James Ruppert (essay date Fall 1991)
- John S. Slack (essay date Summer 1993)
- Roberta Rubenstein (review date 14 November 1993)
- Sidner Larson (essay date 1993)
- Julie Tharp (essay date 1993)
- Lawrence Thornton (review date 16 January 1994)
- Susan Meisenhelder (essay date January 1994)
- Nancy J. Peterson (essay date October 1994)
- Sue Halpern (review date 16 April 1995)
- Mark Childress (review date 12 May 1996)
- Verlyn Klinkenborg (review date 16 June 1996)
- Julie Barak (essay date Fall 1996)
- Thomas Matchie (essay date Fall 1996)
- Susan Castillo (essay date Winter 1996)
- Copyright
