Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Baker, Nicholson - Robert Darnton (review date 26 April 2001)

1. Printable Version
2. Download PDF
3. Cite this Page

Robert Darnton (review date 26 April 2001)

SOURCE: Darnton, Robert. “The Great Book Massacre.” New York Review of Books 48, no. 7 (26 April 2001): 16-19.

[In the following review, Darnton offers a generally favorable assessment of Double Fold, though finds shortcomings in Baker's rhetorical exaggerations and his view of historical sources.]

1.

When journalists discuss their craft, they invoke contradictory clichés: “Today's newspaper is the first draft of history,” and “Nothing is more dead than yesterday's newspaper.” Both in a way are true. News feeds history with facts, yet most of it is forgotten. Suppose newspapers disappeared from libraries: Would history vanish from the collective memory? That is the disaster that Nicholson Baker denounces in his latest book [Double Fold], a J'accuse pointed at the library profession.

Librarians have purged their shelves of newspapers, he argues,...

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass

1. Introduction
2. Principal Works
3. Criticism
   1. Michael Harris (review date 1 April 1990)
   2. Julian Loose (review date 19 April 1991)
   3. Galen Strawson (review date 19 April 1991)
   4. Richard Eder (review date 12 May 1991)
   5. William Scammell (review date 25 May 1991)
   6. Cyra McFadden (review date 9 February 1992)
   7. Peter Kemp (review date 6 March 1992)
   8. James Buchan (review date 14 March 1992)
   9. Julian Loose (review date 26 March 1992)
   10. Robert Towers (review date 9 April 1992)
   11. William H. Pritchard (review date autumn 1992)
   12. Ross Chambers (essay date winter 1994)
   13. Joanne Trestail (review date 6 February 1994)
   14. Richard Eder (review date 13 February 1994)
   15. Trev Broughton (review date 18 February 1994)
   16. Tim Parks (review date 19 February 1994)
   17. Adam Mars-Jones (review date 24 March 1994)
   18. Cathleen Schine (review date 7 April 1994)
   19. Francis Spufford (review date 22 March 1996)
   20. Eric Korn (review date 5 April 1996)
   21. Jim Krusoe (review date 5 May 1996)
   22. Nicholson Baker and David Dodd (interview date 15 May 1996)
   23. Michael Wood (review date 20 June 1996)
   24. Irving Malin (review date fall 1996)
   25. Richard Eder (review date 10 May 1998)
   26. Caroline Moore (review date 13 June 1998)
   27. Ron Charles (review date 25 June 1998)
   28. Eric Lorberer (review date fall 1998)
   29. Arthur Saltzman (essay date 1999)
   30. Leonard Kniffel (essay date April 2001)
   31. Robert Darnton (review date 26 April 2001)
   32. Alexander Star (review date 28 May 2001)
   33. Nicholson Baker and Andrew Richard Albanese (interview date 1 June 2001)
4. Further Reading
5. Copyright