Criticism > Contemporary Literary Criticism > Ambrose, Stephen - Josiah Bunting III (review date 21 December 1998)

1. Printable Version
2. Download PDF
3. Cite this Page

Josiah Bunting III (review date 21 December 1998)

SOURCE: “Fighting Words,” in National Review, December 21, 1998, pp. 60-2.

[In the following review, Bunting offers positive assessment of The Victors and Ambrose's focus on the military experiences of individual soldiers.]

For whom is serious history written? The American academy has long answered: for other university scholars. On occasion, works of academic scholarship become popular: one can think of any number of such books. But in the eyes of university colleagues, their authors as a consequence soon become suspect—quietly derided, yet envied. Historians vulgarly praised as “good writers” are similarly fretted over. Propulsive narrative, pellucid prose, epigrammatical assertion or conclusion, vivid exemplification: such things virtually guarantee the wary regard of other professional historians.

There is a sub-species of history writing that particularly...

Join eNotes

The above is a free excerpt. Get total access to this content with the:

eNotes Pass

1. Introduction
2. Principal Works
3. Criticism
   1. John Keegan (review date 22 October 1984)
   2. Herbert S. Parmet (review date 29 October 1984)
   3. Spencer Warren (review date April 1985)
   4. Richard Harwood (review date 3 May 1987)
   5. Herbert Parmet (review date 4-18 May 1987)
   6. Joan Hoff-Wilson (review date 21 June 1987)
   7. John Charmley (review date 4 July 1987)
   8. Sidney Blumenthal (review date 6 July 1987)
   9. Alan Brinkley (review date 16 July 1987)
   10. Richard John Neuhaus (review date August 1987)
   11. Robert A. Strong (review date Summer 1988)
   12. Robert Dallek (review date 15 October 1989)
   13. John Edward Wilz (review date Summer 1990)
   14. Kevin P. Phillips (review date 24 November 1991)
   15. William L. O'Neill (review date 30 December 1991)
   16. Anthony Howard (review date 1 February 1992)
   17. Esmond Wright (review date July 1992)
   18. James N. Giglio (review date Winter 1993)
   19. John Kentleton (review date February 1994)
   20. Earl F. Ziemke (review date March 1994)
   21. Scott Jaschik (essay date 18 May 1994)
   22. William L. O'Neill (review date 6-20 June 1994)
   23. Carlo d'Este (review date 30 December 1994)
   24. Alan F. Wilt (review date June 1995)
   25. Blaine Harden (review date 11 February 1996)
   26. Alexander Theroux (review date 3 March 1996)
   27. Gordon S. Wood (review date 4 April 1996)
   28. Patricia Nelson Limerick (review date 7 April 1996)
   29. Peter G. Boyle (review date June 1996)
   30. Albert Furtwangler (review date December 1996)
   31. Lisa E. Emmerich (review date Fall 1997)
   32. Howard Lamar (review date October 1997)
   33. Josiah Bunting III (review date 21 December 1998)
   34. Eric T. Dean Jr. (review date June 1999)
   35. Steve Weinberg (review date 3 September 2000)
   36. Patricia Nelson Limerick (review date 18 September 2000)
4. Further Reading
5. Copyright