Criticism > Classical and Medieval Literature Criticism > St. Anselm of Canterbury - Montague Brown (essay date 1994)
St. Anselm of Canterbury - Montague Brown (essay date 1994)
Montague Brown (essay date 1994)
SOURCE: Brown, Montague. “Anselm's Argument for the Necessity of Incarnation.” Proceedings of the PMR Conference (1994): 39-52.
[In the following essay, Brown evaluates and ultimately rejects Anselm's rational claims in his Cur Deus Homo regarding the necessity of God's Incarnation as Christ in order to save humanity.]
In Cur deus homo, Anselm presents a rational argument for the necessity of the Incarnation, an argument suitable for convincing nonbelievers that the Incarnation is not only possible (that is, it does not involve a contradiction), but can be shown, by natural reason alone, to be necessary. Since there are many (believers as well as unbelievers) who do not think that reason can even prove the existence of God, such a claim as Anselm's is rather surprising. Is Anselm's claim credible? In our present inquiry, four subjects are involved—
(1) Anselm's overall...
[The entire page is 6228 words long]
Join eNotes
Over 3,500 study guides, question and answer forums, literature criticism, reference content, and much more!
Navigate
- Introduction
- Principal Works
-
Criticism
- Hugh R. Smart (essay date 1949)
- Norman Malcolm (essay date 1960)
- R. W. Southern (essay date 1963)
- Richard Campbell (essay date 1979)
- A. E. McGrath (essay date July 1981)
- Allan Bäck (essay date 1981)
- Donald F. Duclow (essay date January 1982)
- William Collinge (essay date December 1984)
- Walter Fröhlich (essay date 1984)
- Hugh Feiss (essay date March 1985)
- Aidan Nichols (essay date July 1985)
- Thomas A. Losoncy (essay date 1985)
- William L. Craig (essay date February 1986)
- Drew E. Hinderer (essay date spring 1986)
- Thomas H. Bestul (essay date 1988)
- Frederick Van Fleteren (essay date 1991)
- Richard Law (essay date 1991)
- Paschal Baumstein (essay date March 1992)
- C. J. Mews (essay date 1992)
- J. F. Worthen (essay date 1993)
- Montague Brown (essay date 1994)
- Ryan Topping (essay date February 2002)
- Further Reading
- Copyright
