The Cask of Amontillado Group

Question:

mouzeika
mouzeika
Student
High School - 11th Grade

Is the revenge of the story, "The Cask of Amontillado" acceptable?

Rate question:

Posted by mouzeika on Tuesday July 17, 2007 at 6:04 AM and tagged with fortunato, revenge, the cask of amontillado.

Answers:


  1. jamie-wheeler Teacher
    College - Sophomore

    eNotes Editor

    I would say certainly not.  Murder can never be jusitfied (especially one as brutual and inhumane as this one.)  Furthermore, we never know exactly what Fortunato has done to so enrage the narrator.  The best we can glean from the narrative is that he is a wine snob and something of a bore.  If this criteria justified murder, a good percentage of Dallas (where I live!) would be snuffed out!  :)

    Sources:
    http://www.enotes.com/cask

    Rate answer:

    Posted by jamie-wheeler on Tuesday July 17, 2007 at 6:15 AM

  2. volcomstone
    volcomstone Student
    High School - 12th Grade

    Murder is never acceptable except in certain cases. Whatever Fortunato did to Montrssor, it probably disgraced Montressor's family for him to do such a heinous crime.

    Sources:
    http://www.enotes.com/cask

    Rate answer:

    Posted by volcomstone on Sunday December 9, 2007 at 3:24 PM


  3. brendawm Teacher
    High School - 9th Grade

    eNotes Editor

    I would have to say that, no, the revenge of the story is not acceptable for many reasons.  Perhaps the biggest reason that the revenge here is so unacceptable is that we, the readers, are given no clear cut reason for the revenge.  Montresor was wronged by Fortunato, no specifics, just "wronged"; it seems a little difficult to sympathize with Montresor, a murderer, or accept his actions, when there is nothing to go on.  For example, if Fortunato had harmed someone Montresor  loved out of some evil plot or plan to cause him pain, then you might be able to understand the revenge; however, even though understandable, it is still not necessarily acceptable.  Basically, nothing makes revenge acceptable, but in some cases, revenge is more understandable than others.

    Sources:
    http://www.enotes.com/cask-amontillado/

    Rate answer:

    Posted by brendawm on Thursday January 31, 2008 at 7:48 PM


  4. mrerick Teacher
    High School - 12th Grade

    eNotes Editor

    The most important reason we know the revenge isn't acceptable is because Fortunato doesn't see it coming.  When we study this story, I always pose this question to my students, "What could Fortunato have done to Montressor to deserve these actions."  Students will come up with a great list of stuff, but the thing that really ties them together is that if Fortunato had done any of them, he would know that Montressor would be mad at him.

    We've all accidentally made one of our own friends or acquaintances mad at us without knowing what we said or did would make them mad, but whatever happened didn't justify getting killed for it.  That's what makes Montressor's actions so unreasonable.  What, exactly, could Fortunato have done that was so horrible, but not even know it made Montressor mad??

    Rate answer:

    Posted by mrerick on Thursday January 31, 2008 at 8:20 PM