Noah Webster, first Wikipedian
Monday, October 15th, 2007 “But, sir,” Johnny replies respectfully, “I looked these words up in the dictionary. There is no u in honor. There is no g in jail. And plow only has 4 letters, not 6.” “Good heavens!” the teacher responds. “You’re not using that dictionary by Noah Webster, are you?” “Yes, sir. My dad just bought it last month.” “Johnny, I’m sure your father meant well, but in this class we do NOT use Webster’s Dictionary! We use the tried and true dictionaries published by respected lexicographers in England. We can’t have people just making up their own spellings of words, can we?” Fast forward to 2007. Today many teachers likewise do not allow use of Wikipedia, claiming lack of authoritative scholarship or substantive content. “We can’t have people just making up their own knowledge, can we?” These statements overlook the realities of authorship. While modern scholars might respectfully disagree with some of Webster’s etymologies, no one would deny that his dictionary was carefully researched. Wikipedia, for all its well publicized flaws, has been judged about roughly as reliable as the Encyclopedia Britannica and certainly more timely. The question was the same for Webster as for us: where does “authority” lie? Under what circumstances might one rightly break with tradition and trust one’s own judgment? As we teach our children to look for authority in their information sources, we might also consider the story of Noah Webster. He didn’t work alone, but he is the one we credit with reform in American spelling. He had the courage to consider something new, publish his proposals, and weather the backlash until people thought things through. Perhaps we could consider Noah Webster the first Wikipedian.

Noah WebsterHe was 22 when the Declaration of Independence was signed, just old enough to embrace the Romantic spirit of the age and let it propel him to the end of his days. Noah Webster was passionate about the identity of his new nation, and that zeal lead to publication of a spelling book, a grammar book, and a reader, unique because they were designed specifically for American children. In 1828, he also published the first dictionary of American English, An American Dictionary of the English Language.
Imagine a schoolroom circa 1829. Johnny’s teacher is handing back an essay with several words underlined and corrected in the margin. “Johnny,” he says, “you need to work on your spelling.”
