Assisted Suicide
Assisted Suicide | Bans on Assisted Suicide Violate the Fourteenth Amendment
About the author: Stephen Reinhardt is a circuit judge for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Editor’s Note: The following viewpoint is excerpted from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Compassion in Dying v. State of Washington (1996).
We are required to decide whether a person who is terminally ill has a constitutionally protected liberty interest in hastening what might otherwise be a protracted, undignified, and extremely painful death. If such an interest exists, we must next decide whether or not the state of...
[The entire page is 3480 words long]
Navigate
- Introduction
-
Chapter 1
- Chapter 1 Preface
- Assisted Suicide Shows Compassion for the Dying
- Assisted Suicide Is Consistent with Christian Beliefs
- Christian Arguments Against Assisted Suicide Are Misguided
- Allowing Competent People to Commit Suicide Is Ethical
- Physician-Assisted Suicide Undermines Medical Ethics
- Assisted Suicide Distorts the Meaning of Mercy
- Assisted Suicide Violates Christian Beliefs
- Assisted Suicide Violates the Dignity of Patients
- Assisted Suicide Is Not Morally Equivalent to Letting Patients Die
-
Chapter 2
- Chapter 2 Preface
- Bans on Assisted Suicide Violate the Fourteenth Amendment
- Assisted Suicide Is an Individual Freedom
- Assisted Suicide Is a Fundamental Constitutional Right
- Assisted Suicide Is the Ultimate Civil Right
- Bans on Assisted Suicide Do Not Violate the Fourteenth Amendment
- Arguments Supporting a Constitutional Right to Suicide Are Illogical
- A Constitutional Right to Assisted Suicide Would Threaten Patients’ Right to Refuse Treatment
- The Supreme Court’s Position on Assisted Suicide Is Valid
-
Chapter 3
- Chapter 3 Preface
- Legalized Physician- Assisted Suicide Would Improve Treatment of the Terminally Ill
- Safeguards Can Prevent the Abuse of Physician- Assisted Suicide
- Legalizing Physician- Assisted Suicide Would Not Threaten the Disabled
- Arguments Against Legalizing Physician- Assisted Suicide Are Unconvincing
- Support for Legalized Physician-Assisted Suicide Is Based on Mistaken Notions
- Legalized Physician- Assisted Suicide Would Lead to Abuses
- Legalizing Physician- Assisted Suicide Would Harm Society
- Legalized Physician- Assisted Suicide Would Damage the Physician- Patient Relationship
-
Chapter 4
- Chapter 4 Preface
- Assisted Suicide Would Threaten the Nonfatally Ill
- Assisted Suicide Would Threaten the Rights of the Disabled
- Assisted Suicide Would Create an Inhumane Society
- Assisted Suicide Will Be Encouraged for Economic Reasons
- Assisted Suicide Would Respect the Rights of the Terminally Ill
- Assisted Suicide Would Respect the Rights of the Elderly
- Voluntary Euthanasia Would Not Lead to Involuntary Killing
- Some Individuals Have a Duty to Die
- Organizations to Contact
- Bibliography
- Copyright
Tell a friend about Assisted Suicide at eNotes.
