Home > A Separate Peace Summary & Study Guide > A Separate Peace Group > Discussion Board

What about the novel's conclusion was satisfying, and what was disappointing?

From a literary perspective, the conclusion of the novel is satisfying in that it is consistent with the nature of the characters as they have been developed throughout the story. Also, the conclusion effectively "ties up" the novel's numerous themes in regard to youth, friendship, war, and self-knowledge. A different ending would have seemed contrived and unconvincing.

From a personal perspective, the conclusion is simply sad. How sad it is that these boys have endured so much emotional suffering as their world has been turned upside down by forces beyond their control, how sad that they have lived in such emotional isolation with no steadying adult leadership to help them through their conflicts. Each one has had to struggle alone, and the effects of their fear and confusion are difficult to experience in the novel's conclusion. The fact that Gene walks away with a greater understanding of himself and human nature in general is fine, but his knowledge is gained at an enormously high price.